rihanna-dior-cruise-2015_garance-dore

It’s not the first time we’ve talked about celebrities becoming style icons (I know you remember Garance’s post on Kim Kardashian that drove some of you so mad…) so today, let’s talk about Rihanna.

She sported a dramatic number from Stella McCartney at the Met Ball (I wonder what Charles James would think about a crop top…) and she was at the Dior cruise show last week wearing head-to-toe pieces from the house. She’s going to be honored at this year’s CFDA Awards as Fashion Icon of the year. And of course, you can’t forget, she’s the face of spring Balmain.

I can’t really comment too much on Rihanna’s off duty style outside of saying it’s pretty casual and maybe a little bit flashy at times (her Instagram was recently deleted, so I can’t go back through her #OOTD posts), but is she on her way to becoming a major fashion player?

If you have Stella and Raf wanting to dress you, a major ad campaign and an award on the way, I think it gives you some serious fashion street cred. So what do you think? Is Rihanna someone with great style or is it all about celebrity status?


You may also like

  • She Did It Again
    Contributors
    She Did It Again
  • The Selfie Book
    Contributors
    The Selfie Book
  • A beauty minute with Jessica
    Beauty
    A beauty minute with...
  • Sneaker Couture
    Contributors
    Sneaker Couture

105 comments

Add yours
  • Tat May, 16 2014, 9:15 / Reply

    Celebrity status that’s all, like Kim K, and the rest. They definitely don’t hold a candle to any of you stylish bunch at the office!

  • andreea May, 16 2014, 9:15

    a good stylist does not mean great personal style. just look at gaga: the minute formicheti took his hands off her, her relevance plummeted… :)

    http://littleaesthete.com

  • MissPimpin May, 16 2014, 9:28 / Reply

    Je trouve qu’elle est – évidemment – très jolie, et que du coup elle peut tout se permettre, ce qu’elle fait d’ailleurs, et le plus souvent, ce n’est pas très heureux. Je ne crois pas qu’elle ait le moindre sens du style ni de la mode

  • Olivia May, 16 2014, 9:28

    Tout à fait d’accord !

  • Clao May, 16 2014, 9:28

    Tout à fait d’accord.

  • Viola May, 16 2014, 9:29 / Reply

    She’s truly gorgeous. Beautiful body, face, skin… but i don’t think that she’s a true fashion icon. It’s about the visibility that she provides through stardom.

  • holly May, 16 2014, 9:29

    couldn’t agree more!

  • Barbara May, 16 2014, 9:30 / Reply

    I’ve been wondering about this for a while: does a celebrity deserve to be called a style icon when there is such a definitive line between “off duty” style, as you call it, and “on duty”? Clearly someone other than Rihanna herself is responsible for her on duty looks. This is obvious by her off duty style, which, as seen at last night’s Clippers/Thunder game, is somewhat horrendous.

  • Caroline Mt May, 16 2014, 9:30 / Reply

    Elle est très bien habillée (depuis 1 ou 2 ans, c’est vraiment bien) mais c’est l’oeuvre d’une ou plusieurs stylistes. Tiens d’ailleurs ce serait intéressant de savoir qui c’est, pour le féliciter!

  • Tara May, 16 2014, 9:30 / Reply

    Another version of the Style vs. Fashion question.

    I don’t think Rhianna is an icon – she’s beautiful and definitely has her own spin on things but when it comes to these fashion choices, she’s eye candy, an enticement meant to buy street credibility and sell clothes. It’s not a bad thing but it isn’t the same as seeing someone you’ve never heard of walk across the street in front of you in a head-turning ensemble that opens a window in your head and makes you think of your own clothes in a new way.

    Style is about your own choices. Fashion is usually about someone else’s.

    To me, that’s a real style setter.

  • Aliya May, 16 2014, 9:30

    Great response.

  • veronica May, 16 2014, 9:31 / Reply

    I am sincere, even if she is a beautiful girl, I do not really like her style!!!
    Kiss!
    Passa a trovarmi VeryFP

  • Tiani May, 16 2014, 9:33 / Reply

    I think a celebrity can buy style, so if I see one with an outfit I like … I think ‘nice outfit’ or outfits(s). I don’t think of them as an icon because they have a stylist (or a team) and tons of money and time to plan what they are wearing for events where they’ll be photographed. All-in-all, I’d call it celebrity status in this case. Fashion seems so staged and manufactured with celebrities. I don’t feel like I see enough spontaneous fashion moments or like we just happened upon a person in their normal everyday life looking chic. I’m just so over it.

  • Amanda May, 16 2014, 9:35 / Reply

    Love Rihanna and her amazing style! Definitely think she is on her way to becoming a style icon–plus she always has the best hair and makeup transformations. Remember her asymmetrical cut in Umbrella? And her super badass red hair?

  • Melissa May, 16 2014, 9:40 / Reply

    Unlike Kim K and all the “reality” stars, Rhianna is a very talented singer and entertainer…..and she also has great style…………we always want to see what she is wearing……….and she is more credible as no matter whose clothes she wears she makes it her own…..

  • Suze May, 16 2014, 9:44 / Reply

    Although she can sometimes look really cool (and I loved how she rocked short hair – too few female celebrities do), I don’t think she’s refined enough (well, quite often she looks downright trashy) to be a true style icon.
    I think to be a fashion icon you really need to have your personality shine through and have some sort of consistency in how you dress (not to say you can’t change it up ofcourse) and that’s something Rihanna doesn’t display.

  • Kendriana May, 16 2014, 9:48 / Reply

    I’ve always admired Rhianna’s style! It’s so edgy, creative and bold! Plus she’s always been a trendsetter for my age group. Of course, these are all opinions (awards included,) but Rhianna has a great influence on street style so I think that makes her an icon. SJP is an actress and she’s considered a style icon, while Rhianna and Sarah Jessica Parker have different style, the concept of celebrity turned fashion icon is still the same. Some people may not like urban style but it’s just as much “real” fashion as anything else.

  • jett May, 16 2014, 9:48

    Agree-I always want to see what she’s wearing, eons ago, I wanted to see what Farrah Faucet was wearing–cool girl style.

  • Samy May, 16 2014, 9:53 / Reply

    How much is cool this girl?

    Pls take a look @ http://thehippiewhim.blogspot.it/

    XO
    S.

  • Erdene May, 16 2014, 10:00 / Reply

    This is little different from what Rihanna would normally wear. She is looking pretty here.
    (Also please visit my website when you have time ^_^)

  • Virginie May, 16 2014, 10:00 / Reply

    Je me permets une petite remarque : beaucoup trop de termes anglais dans ce post… Je ne comprends pas la moitié de ce qui est écrit… Rihanna en mode off-duty ????

  • Justyna May, 16 2014, 10:03 / Reply

    I don’t think it’s fair calling her a celebrity and putting next to Kim K. She’s a singer, she became a celebrity because of her singing (let’s not get into the value of her music now, ok?) and not because of a sex tape or having a fake wedding on TV.
    Like it or not Rihanna sells her albums in millions and has huge world tours where she sings.
    I think by her fashion choices she’s doing a lot of good to the industry. Her style has evolved so much lately that I really think she deserves this award.
    P.S. Alex, show us what you wore to the cruise, girl!

  • christine May, 16 2014, 10:03

    agreed!! the difference is rihanna has TALENT, she creates, and the creativity spills over from music into clothing. kim k’s only pursuit is being a mannequin and being seen. that being said, rihanna definitely has the advantage of money and access. but if you follow her closely, even her “off-duty” outfits show that she has a distinct style and her personality is intimately reflected in her clothing choices. her styled (by others) “on-duty” outfits are just the cherry on top.

  • gaptoothedgirl May, 16 2014, 10:04 / Reply

    I love her, even when dressed up as a romantic girl, she’s so strong!
    xox, Gap.
    http://www.gaptoothedgirl.com

  • CC May, 16 2014, 10:09 / Reply

    I know that the “celebrity as style icon” debate has been happening for years because it’s hard to know what’s truly innate vs. working with a great team of people. That’s why street style is generally so much more interesting to me because it’s, in general, a more authentic creative expression. Credible or not, at least Rihanna tries to go against the grain, thought it doesn’t personally jive with my own aesthetic tastes.

    http://www.enduringethereal.com

  • Lo May, 16 2014, 10:15 / Reply

    J’adore, elle est clairement ma référence numéro 1 en matière de mode. Meme dans ses vêtements du quotidien.
    Elle ose, elle est moderne, elle porte ce qui lui plait, ce qui l’amuse et elle s’en fout, c’est pas la définition de la mode ça ?

  • sev May, 16 2014, 10:19 / Reply

    c’est une badgirl, et elle adore ca. Elle n’en a jamais assez d’être regardée, et fait tout pour attirer les regards, c’est donc un porte manteaux rentable pour les marques. Mais franchement c’est pas une fille gentille ni sympa (cf le dernier scandale ou elle se fout de sa fan), qui traine avec des mecs qui frappent les filles, bref… Ca me désole et je trouve ca plutot triste. :(

  • Caroline Mt May, 16 2014, 10:24 / Reply

    J’ai trouvé!
    Le styliste (principal en tout cas) de Rihanna est Mel Ottenberg.
    Quant à Kim K, pas moyen de trouver le nom de son styliste, mais en revanche on sait qu’elle fait retoucher tous ses pantalons par Cornelius Clay, un des stylistes de Kanye (ce qui est une très bonne idée, vu la galère que c’est pour trouver un pantalon qui siet parfaitement).

  • Gala May, 16 2014, 10:31 / Reply

    I am really bothered by celebrity worship. I stopped buying American fashion magazines because they only use celebrities on the covers. It’s too much like the idea of the “popular kids” in high school. I just don’t want to always see the same people! Add to the fact that many of them have “brands” and it’s like watching commercials all the time!

  • Tiani May, 16 2014, 10:31

    Amen!

  • Candace May, 16 2014, 10:31

    My mother summed it up during the time of Rhianna’s unfortunate and disturbing debacle with Chris Brown:

    ‘Silly young kids with way too much money’. That’s all she is, silly and from the looks of it, a mean girl. Gorgeous for sure, talented never (she doesn’t ‘sing’, she “entertains”, but most people don’t know the difference). “Style” with a capital S….nope, no, no-ish!

    Having tons of money and wearing head to toe brands doesn’t make one stylish, not in today’s world, not ever. She is a commodity, to be bought and sold, not an icon. She isn’t strong, nor is she empowered, (unless you count vulgar materialism empowering.) Her shtick will get very old by the time she gets in her 30′s, in which case another will have taken her place.

    Can we stop making these mediocre people even more insanely rich and famous with our misplaced admiration please?

  • ensse May, 16 2014, 10:32 / Reply

    Elle modernise tout ce qu’elle touche,
    elle est définitivement la fille de l’époque,
    avant la prochaine….

  • Emma May, 16 2014, 10:35 / Reply

    A la base j’étais une fan de Rihanna, mais ça c’était avant.
    Je dois admettre que l’attitude de plus en plus provoc’ de Riri ne m’aide pas. Mon avis est trop vicié pour que je puisse en donner un totalement objectif.
    Elle est TROP vulgaire et ses OOTD sont inégaux, mais j’avoue tout de même que lors de certains évènements mondains, il y a des tenus qui ont de la gueule. Donc je dirais que son styliste pour ce genre d’occasion a dû goût. Donc je ne qualifierai pas Rihanna d’icône mode parce qu’elle ne m’inspire pas du tout. Elle met certes des vêtements de marque mais ça ne me marque pas, ça ne me choque pas dans le bon sens…Elle n’éblouit pas le vêtement car elle n’apporte rien de plus malgré sa personnalité dynamique et son comportement trop sexy.
    Kim K se rachète une conduite, elle évolue dans le bon sens surtout côté look. Il suffit de regarder ses OOTD, j’aime vraiment c’est choix.
    Taylor Swift (que je trouve niaise et insupportable) a un style qui lui va tellement bien, que j’ai l’impression qu’elle me raconte une histoire rien qu’avec ses vêtements.
    Pour Riri c’est mort, je ne l’apporte plus vraiment dans mon coeur, elle a réussi à devenir la Beyoncé du pauvre…

  • claire May, 16 2014, 10:46 / Reply

    Je n’aime pas cette fille,je trouve qu’il est très vulgare¡

  • Mamzette May, 16 2014, 11:04 / Reply

    Moi, j’ai envie de dire qu’elle porte ce qui lui plait, fait ce qu’elle veut et l’assume haut et fort. Et que c’est ça, la vraie crédibilité.

  • Cristiana May, 16 2014, 11:11 / Reply

    While I can understand why everybody loves to talk about her, to me Rihanna is neither a fashion icon nor a stylish girl.

  • fashionsphinx May, 16 2014, 11:17 / Reply

    If you have style you do not follow fashion , you CREATE fashion.

    I have had the Rihanna debate with my friends in the fashion industry many times….does she have it ? does she not ?
    One thing is for sure….you cannot compare her to KK….KK really does NOT have it , and never will unfortunately, you can just tell

    Rihanna’s style is street and sassy , she wears clothes as a form of self expression and not in order to please men, she dares, she risks, she misses a lot of the times, looks like a hot fashion mess on many occasions , I do not particularly like that form of ” pop porn ” music nor branding nor styling nor marketing ( in the same category as Beyonce and Miley : part stripper show , part Las Vegas show and some little bits of music in between ) but unfortunately this is what the record companies want and expect from these girls because this is what sells ….and don’t get me started on the music industry ….

    Rihanna as fashion icon ? don’t think so IMO . Rihanna has fashion sense ? yes she does , you can tell she loves fashion and is well informed , has a lot of money to buy the latest statement pieces and good stylists to provide her with the rest .

    As I said above : you have to create fashion to have style….and this is not happening with Rihanna’s case , but at least she is having fun , innit ?

    http://www.fashionsphinx.com

  • ananta May, 16 2014, 11:35 / Reply

    When I have seen Rihanna in person, she is absolutely stunning. … And for all intents and purposes, she is quite influential as far as fashion goes, but fashion is not style. I think that the connoisseurs of fashion have somehow merged these two. Style transcends the fashions. I am not sure that we have many that have true style independent of fashion. Meanwhile…I definitely enjoy what’s out there.

  • JK May, 16 2014, 11:41 / Reply

    Does she have a style to speak of?! I don’t think so, and she’s lightyears away from being any kind of icon, so no, I don’t think she is a style icon.
    Sorry for sounding b*****, but the last thing I read about her was about her making mean comments about a fan of hers, so I don’t see a reason to hold back, sorry.

  • Mimi May, 16 2014, 11:44 / Reply

    Mode si vous voulez mais alors pas classe du tout! Et je suis désolée qu’elle devienne une référence, encore plus une icône.
    Bien sûr il faut être libre et avant-gardiste mais c’est mieux d’être créatif et personnel sans céder en permanence à a vulgarité. Elle en devient “commune” et sans intérêt, c’est domage pour elle mais ses efforts (où eux de ses stylistes…) ne payent pas.

  • alix de Beer May, 16 2014, 11:45 / Reply

    Canoon cette photo d’elle ;-)
    Alixxx
    http://alixdebeer.com

  • Stephanie May, 16 2014, 11:45 / Reply

    She definitely beautiful, and she does seem to often pull together really interesting looks. I will just say though that her bad rep is really catching up with her – Did you hear about that young girl who dressed like her to go to the prom and then got humiliated by her on Twitter? I just found that so trashy – its worse than like Naomi Campbell throwing cell phones…

  • juli May, 16 2014, 12:00 / Reply

    Doesn’t Count if someone else is almost always dressing you…

    Someone like Solange may be [crazy] but SHE has style.

  • Dottie May, 16 2014, 12:02 / Reply

    Celebrity status only.

  • Alexander May, 16 2014, 12:04 / Reply

    I think Rihanna is really beautiful, but I don’t know if it’s the result of her teams of stylists, makeup artists, publishers, and assistants or she DOES pick her own clothes all alone. My definition of style icon is someone who has a huge voice (or opinion) in fashion and she/he can apply it on his/her everyday look without the help of professionals. So… I guess Rihanna is like half-icon?

    http://peppermintswing.tumblr.com/

  • Aliya May, 16 2014, 12:07 / Reply

    I think they should give her stylist the award.

  • nelly May, 16 2014, 12:08 / Reply

    Quand des grandes marques l’habillent ( comme Stella McCartney ), elle est magnifique, mais si il n’y a personne qui l’aide ça part tout de suite dans le vulgaire comme j’ai pu voir quand elle était invitée à la fashionweek en France, je ne vois pas du tout le côté classe de ne presque rien porter, mais le trash fait vendre apparemment. Je regrette le temps, ou il fallait s’habiller, avec certes du style, mais surtout de l’élégance, maintenant elles sont toutes quasi nu sur le redcarpet

  • swingsnowman May, 16 2014, 12:16 / Reply

    Partly due to the celebrity status.
    But still she is pretty!!
    I love her iconic oversize boyish style. It’s so urban chic. It’s sth that only few of people can handle , which she carries it very well.

    http://swingsnowman.blogspot.hk/

  • sarah May, 16 2014, 12:30 / Reply

    The only reason creative designers compete to see their creation wear by Kim K or Rihanna is because they know that their creation will be seen by every one everywhere and so be bought. Rihanna might be gorgeous but I believe she has no sense of style at all, she just has the fame that makes what she wears desirable and thats why Dior wants to have her front row. It all about money money money

  • M. May, 16 2014, 12:30

    I agree. She’s famous and will be seen.

    I find her extremely vulgar.

  • maryse May, 16 2014, 12:34 / Reply

    Je pense que c’est surtout lié à son statut de people. Elle est très jolie, mais je n’aime pas spécialement son style vestimentaire. C’est une question de goût mais au delà de ça, je pense qu’elle est bien habillée quand les grandes marques l’aident, mais sinon j’adhère pas. Parfois et souvent elle est trop vulgaire je trouve.

  • Nini piccola May, 16 2014, 12:44 / Reply
  • Alice May, 16 2014, 12:57 / Reply

    Hello,

    je ne sais pas trop si elle est la plus grande icone mode de l’annee mais elle a quand meme un sacre sens du style ! Et surtout ce que j’aime c’est qu’elle ose ! Ok elle nous a déjà fait des looks beurk mais en même temps je me disais “c’est cool, elle assume, elle ose, elle se cherche, elle innove” et donc du coup elle est créative! et ça c’est respect, car maintenant tout va tellement vite que même les tendances sont obsolètes. Par exemple, apres 1 mois, on voit toutes les blogueuses habillées (aux prémices elles étaient précurseurs et développaient leur créativité mais aujourd”hui au global – car il y a des exceptions of course – tout est un peu incipide, non ? ) de la même manière et dans la rue aussi. Alors Rihanna, rayonnante, épanouie, wonderwoman, je dis OUI OUI OUI ! ;-)

    xx

    http://www.kitschissime.com/

  • mimi taylor May, 16 2014, 1:06 / Reply

    definitely star status, her personal taste is yuk and as for Kim, she’s not a natural beauty, she’s man made.

  • Sarah May, 16 2014, 1:31 / Reply

    “people” non. C’est une rock star. pas une people.
    Les rock stars ils ont pas besoin d”avoir du style” comme toutes les fashionistas qui lisent ce blog… ILS MENENT le style. Ils definissent le style.

  • Ève May, 16 2014, 1:31 / Reply

    Je pense que de mettre de jolis vêtements sur quelqu’un de vulgaire et qui n’a aucun sens profond du style n’en fera jamais une icône de la mode. Les icônes sont celles dont la personnalité induisent le style, et non l’inverse.

  • Pauline Moi Non Plus May, 16 2014, 1:38 / Reply

    Pour moi c’est clairement dû à son statut de “star” mondiale ;) et qu’elle est devenue naturellement un produit marketing puisque suivie par des millions de personnes … Mais sur elle, ça marche ! L’inspiration et l’admiration de ses tenues fonctionne, alors pourquoi ne pas l’apprécier après tout ;) !!!

    Les Selfies de Pauline
    http://lesselfiesdepauline.blogspot.fr

  • elise May, 16 2014, 2:12 / Reply

    eh ben moi je l’aime d’amour Rihanna. Je la trouve magnifique, culottée, j’aime ses looks complètement déglingue, bref, une nana cool! Je ne la qualifierais pas de vulgaire. Dès qu’une femme est un peu sexuelle, elle est classée dans cette catégorie.. Pour moi, Kim K est atrocement vulgaire, mais pas Rihanna.

  • Cat May, 16 2014, 2:13 / Reply

    Si avoir un sens du style aiguisé c’est d’être super vulgaire alors oui elle est pile dans la tendance !

  • Mary May, 16 2014, 2:15 / Reply

    I think Rihanna has a beautiful face and she is slim enough to fit into designer samples, and she is obviously a talented singer, but I agree with what others have said here–she is no style icon. If anything, I think her real style is a bit trashy and she relies too much on showing skin. But, of course, since she is such a huge celebrity, designers want to dress her because that way their clothes will be seen and Rihanna’s fans will want to emulate her look.

    I think the phrase “style icon” is a bit overused these days. To me, a real icon is someone like Audrey Hepburn, Kate Moss, Jane Birkin, or Giovanna Battaglia. Someone who has a consistent look that is all their own, whether they are dressed in designer duds for an event or their own clothes for everyday life.

    Mary
    http://myfrenchexperiment.blogspot.com

  • M May, 16 2014, 2:30 / Reply

    I’d say money has a lot to do with what she wears, which is the case with any other especially wealthy person most of the time.
    Having said that, Rihanna’s definitely got that cool girl edge which filters through whatever the outfit may be… Which is more than I can say for Kim Kardashian.

    http://www.creataurus.co.uk

  • elise May, 16 2014, 2:31 / Reply

    moi je pense que Karl, qui fait toujours des choix audacieux, devrait collaborer avec elle.Je suis étonnée que ce ne soit pas déjà fait!

  • Daniella May, 16 2014, 2:43 / Reply

    Maybe i’m being ignorant but I feel anyone can become a style icon if Stella McCartney, Raf Simons and those alike are dressing you, no?! Though I will say she is undeniably beautiful and always looks amazing in the clothes she is styled in.

    Daniella xx

  • vvn May, 16 2014, 3:28 / Reply

    I think her style helped elevate her celebrity status. Remember RiRi’s Pon de Replay days?? No one really cared about her til she lopped her hair off and Jay Z took her under his wing. Then she started wearing flashy outfits that got the media’s attention, regardless of whether the outfits were “nice” or “good,” and that probably helped draw designers’ attention to her too. Now her celebrity status gets her style too. It’s totally circular!

  • Lovely by johanna May, 16 2014, 4:09 / Reply

    Quand on a beaucoup d’argent, il devient bien plus aisé d’avoir son propre style, on peut se permettre d’acheter ce que l’on aime vraiment, !!
    et quand on a un personal shopper, un styliste, un coiffeur, un maquilleur et un photographe (ect..)pour être conseillée , un style en ressort forcement, non?
    Après, Je pense qu’elle n’a pas volé sa célébrité, she’s such a hard worker!

  • Elizaveta May, 16 2014, 4:09 / Reply

    I love Ri’s style…but yes, as it has been mentioned half of that CFDA icon style award goes to Mel Ottenberg – the other half to Ri and he “bad” vibes.

  • Fille à la Modz May, 16 2014, 4:29 / Reply

    Je ne trouve pas qu’elle ait vraiment un style qui se démarque et que les autres aimeraient adopter. C’est son statut de star qui la propulse ainsi.

  • Olivia May, 16 2014, 4:34 / Reply

    Elle est une célébrité, donc est très médiatisée, on la voit partout, donc bonne opportunité pour les marques de se faire encore plus voir ?

  • La déco de N May, 16 2014, 5:16 / Reply

    C’est clairement une fashion icon pour des millions de personnes, mais ce n’est pas une icône pour moi.
    Mais heureusement que nous n’aimons pas toutes les mêmes choses.
    Et bien sur que son statut d’icône de mode est lié à son statut de star… comme 99% des icônes

    http://www.love-deco-design.blogspot.fr

  • Alix May, 16 2014, 5:46 / Reply

    Honnetement je pense qu’elle a une bonne styliste et encore il y a des jours off! Perso je ne suis pas super fana, trop de provoc et souvent trop border line mais par contre elle a une super ligne que tout a chacun pouvait admirer dans les details – merci Instagram – boo hoo c’est fini!
    Alors est ce qu’elle tiendra la distance…
    Merci Alex
    Bon weekend et bisous
    Alix
    http://www.blushandbeyond.net/

  • Nanie May, 16 2014, 5:57 / Reply

    Je pense effectivement que son statut de people y est pour beaucoup. La célébrité permet à de nombreuses stars de se mettre aux goûts du jour sans qu’elles n’aient réellement un sens du style.
    Selon moi, quand on est une vraie icône de la mode, ça se ressent dès le début, alors qu’on ne peut pas dire que Rihanna s’est vraiment distinguée d’un point de vue vestimentaire à ses débuts.

  • Claire May, 16 2014, 6:16 / Reply

    I like her, I like her songs, but.. for me she’s not that ‘fashion icon’ with big F.

  • eveie b May, 16 2014, 6:28 / Reply

    I think Rihanna is a beautiful girl and makes anything she puts on look good! Oh, how I miss those days.
    That’s not to say she doesn’t bring her own street cred. We’ve seen her grow up in the industry to be the rockin’ diva she is. I get her songs stuck in my head all the time.

  • princessglee May, 16 2014, 7:59 / Reply

    I’ve got 4 things to say about Ri Ri, BCBG (Bon Chic, Bon Genre, Good taste, good style.)

  • Ora May, 16 2014, 8:10 / Reply

    It’s strange that you decided to post this piece about Rihanna’s style the same week that Rihanna has been publicly mocking her 16 year old fashion fans on twitter for their clothing. Random cruelty is a very bad look.
    See various coverage, for example:
    http://www.billboard.com/articles/news/6091820/rihanna-insults-teenage-fan-for-wearing-similar-outfit
    http://hollywoodlife.com/2014/05/15/rihanna-mocks-fan-prombat-outfit-cruel-instagram-diss/

  • Maria May, 16 2014, 8:10 / Reply

    Rhianna.. she’s pretty and all, but she’s not a fashion icon by any means. I don’t know how I feel about this blog after this post….

  • Tessa May, 16 2014, 9:33 / Reply

    You guys are deluded — Rihanna is already a major fashion icon. Best dressed at the Met Ball, CFDA Fashion Icon of the Year, and spring Balmain. She is fly as hell and you’re missing it.

    Hip-hop is high fashion. If all you have to say about Rihanna’s streetwear is “a little bit flashy,” you’ve been listening to too much Lorde and not enough A$AP Rocky. Don’t apologize for celebrating fashion icons of color.

  • Eunice May, 16 2014, 9:33

    I agree with you Tessa; they love the culture but they don’t like the people.

  • Elora May, 16 2014, 11:03 / Reply

    I love Rihanna. So fashion forward even in 2007!!!!

  • Mathilde May, 17 2014, 3:38 / Reply

    Je travaille dans une très grande maison et, dans les services de com et de presse c’est toujours un enfer quand on doit communiquer sur elle (comme dire qu’elle a porté tel modèle de notre collection du moment). Elle passe vraiment pour une “pouffe” (pardonnez-moi l’expression). Ceci dit, je pense qu’elle a effectivement un bon potentiel et qu’en s’améliorant (notamment au niveau du comportement), ça pourrait fonctionner. À voir !

  • Lucy Lumtzerova May, 17 2014, 3:48 / Reply

    she´s a fashion player but not an icon cute rihanna love her music and style

  • D.korneliussen May, 17 2014, 4:05 / Reply

    Words such as “icon” and “genius” should perhaps be saved for certain contexts. Though Rhyana is a fabulous looking creature and has made her mark (as thousands of other young girls have) in the music world… She is – from my perspective – not in the category of “iconic”.

  • eve May, 17 2014, 4:35 / Reply

    Rihanna is a trendsetter for fads not a style icon.

  • Laura May, 17 2014, 4:58 / Reply

    Photo très réussie ; mais une fille aussi vulgaire ne peut pas devenir icône de mode. Ni jolie, ni classe, on ne la catégorise ainsi que parce qu’elle est une “star” de la chanson…

  • Mariateresa May, 17 2014, 5:30 / Reply

    Rihanna c’est trop belle! Elle est magnifique! Bisou Ici Bari!

  • Enkelejda May, 17 2014, 6:42 / Reply

    I believe to be a fashion icon you need an element of class. Also the word icon is overused in the North American society.

    How can we place her in the fashion world when most time she has barely any clothes on, using nudity as shock factor. Wearing fewer pieces of clothing is not daring is boring.

    Garance I love your blog. It is a escape for me, please do not ruin it by using “pop tarts”.

    Thanks, Enekelejda

  • Chanel May, 17 2014, 7:20 / Reply

    Très jolie la Riri, comme d’habitude!

    http://chanelmovement.blogspot.com/

  • Lizzie May, 17 2014, 7:43 / Reply

    Will it kill her to wear a bra? She is absolutely gorgeous but does not come across as well turned-out. In spite of the make-up and designer brands, she always seems undone in a very unflattering way. Won’t her stylist or anyone point out the obvious? This top needs a foundation (as in a properly fitted bra — ok, any bra at all). She needs to put in a bit more effort to obtain the title of ‘fashion icon’.

  • AElitis May, 17 2014, 9:32 / Reply

    She has the money, the face, the body, but is classless. As a young woman, I do NOT look up to her and am not enchanted to do so just because she wears high end brands. People give importance to such shallow things lately…

  • june May, 17 2014, 1:34 / Reply

    I think you can said that someone have a great style is when we saw her outfit on daily time or on off duty time. Maybe she’s trendsetter but I’m not sure she’s fashion icon. wear a high end clothes are not enough to gain a fashion icon status.

  • La pose mode May, 17 2014, 6:48 / Reply

    Super jolie – comme toujours ;)
    Des bises !!

    http://laposemode.blogspot.fr/

  • Susanna Vesna May, 18 2014, 12:56 / Reply

    Its her celebrity status and amount of followers that secure her clothes from big designers. Otherwise, the only self-styling that she manages can only be called “very sl*ty”! (Pardon my French :P)

  • Angie May, 18 2014, 4:54 / Reply

    With Rihanna I sometimes absolutely loathe what she’s wearing and sometimes I totally adore it. But I wonder whether she’s is actually the one with the great sense of style. We all know celebreties oftenly get sent clothes by designers for them to wear and that they have stylists to make them look as awesome as they can be. This is when we have to ponder if it is Rihanna with the great sense of style or just the people that eventually “dress” her. She obviously doesn’t always have these people with her to pick out her clothes, but these are the people that might have influenced the RiRi-style everyone loves so much.

  • Janis May, 18 2014, 10:44 / Reply

    Just this week Rihannna was called out for making fun of a high school girl who was a huge fan. The reason? The girl copied one of Rihanna’s outfits for her prom. Making fun of people is never OK. But it’s especially cruel if you are a celebrity, bullying a young girl. I lost any respect I had for Rihanna.

  • Blonde Mondays May, 18 2014, 12:04 / Reply

    I tend not to call someone with an army of stylists a fashion icon.
    But I think Rihanna dresses pretty well sometimes. Lately I’ve noticed Blake Lively on red carpets. She was stunning but then again… an army of stylists… Naaay.

  • Yassira May, 18 2014, 2:08 / Reply

    We love her flawless skin!

    http://www.sablebeauty.com

  • Rathna Sharad May, 18 2014, 3:51 / Reply

    Love that she is fearless!

  • Natashia May, 18 2014, 9:25 / Reply

    I don’t think she’s a style icon at all.. just because she is given an outfit to wear, doesn’t mean she is stylish. Her off duty clothing choices are horrible and tacky. Someone like Emmanuelle Alt is a style icon because her daily style choices are always spot on – she rocks a certain style that people everywhere try to imitate.

  • nomnom May, 18 2014, 11:39 / Reply

    Love her outfit above. Stylish? It looks tasteful, pretty, safe. She herself, however, makes it look dangerous rather than simply expensive fashion. Perhaps, even, cheap? Most of the comments above are about the difference between the idea of the person (i.e. as icon) and the way the person conducts their life, especially in terms of the media representation of them and how they are styled professionally. How do you actually differentiate between the two? Why bother? As long as we blur that line (as R does herself) between the image and the real woman then we can continue to aspire to her “personal” style. Just by defining ‘style’ as a personal quality we can draw a line between (personal) style and (institutional) fashion. And that confusion between the two categories makes high fashion *feel* more accessible to us even though it is completely unaffordable for most of us. It’s just good old capitalism at work. Rihanna is making it work for herself. So is Stella et al. And so is this blog. The category of the “personal” is for sale, as it should be if you want fashion to sell in this system. Rihanna gets it and she’s good at it. In short, she is adept at conflating style and fashion. And we keep on talking about it, too.

  • Caroline May, 19 2014, 8:43 / Reply

    Non non et non ! Uniquement une people ! Elle n’a aucun style ! Et si l’on regarde ses OOTD, ça n’est absolument pas remarquable ! Trop de vulgarité et de too much. Kim K ou Rihanna, OUT ! On préfère Garance en icône du style ;)

  • Elizabeth Sweeney May, 19 2014, 1:44 / Reply

    I love Rihanna. I think she takes so many fashion risks and they usually end up being chic and fabulous! She is edgy and timeless all in one. Definitely deserves a style icon award for sure!

    visit my fashion blog: http://lizsween.wordpress.com

  • Le bazhaar May, 20 2014, 5:28 / Reply

    Oui et non. Je trouve qu’elle a beaucoup de style qu’elle a acquis au fil des années, c’est sur qu’avoir un styliste talentueux aide, mais j’imagine qu’elle a son mot a dire et que son gout s’est affirme… Elle a le don de savoir detourner et s’approprier les pieces des plus grands designers, ce que tout le monde ne sait pas faire! Aujourd’hui elle est clairement influente dans le domaine de la mode
    http://www.lebazhaar.com

  • Faux Fancy May, 23 2014, 12:24 / Reply

    LOVE this side of Rihanna. This side is a fashion icon. Unfortunately, it isn’t a side we see often enough.

    xoxo,

    Kristen + MK
    http://www.FauxFancy.com

In The Spotlight